This morning Nigel Topping, Chair of the UK Climate Change Committee (CCC), sent a letter to the UK Government (it is addressed to the Secretary of State for Transport, but is copied to the Prime Minister and to several other Cabinet Ministers). Ostensibly the letter has been sent in order “to set out the Committee’s position on the Zero-Emission Vehicle (ZEV) Mandate Review”, but it seems likely that a copy accompanied a press release, for both the BBC and the Guardian wasted no time in preparing articles about it and posting them on their respective websites.
The curious thing is that one assumes that the CCC has already submitted its detailed response, since the Review states (paragraphs 22 and 27 on page 12):
The consultation period began on 14 August 2026 and will run for 10 weeks until 23 October 2026. Please ensure that your response reaches us before the closing date….We will only accept responses received before the closing date: 11:59pm on 23 October 2026.
The CCC members know, therefore, that the letter sent by Mr Topping today, is – or should be – of no value to the Government when it arrives at its conclusions. Why, then, was the letter sent? We can only speculate, but it seems likely that it was intended to be useful propaganda, and that it would faithfully be given publicity by the usual suspects (as it has been).
The BBC seems, if anything, to be a greater cheerleader than the Guardian. Its (the BBC’s) piece is headed “Government risks missing climate targets if EV rules weakened, adviser warns”, and it quotes extensively and uncritically from the letter, with not so much as a hint of an analysis of the CCC’s claims by the esteemed BBC Verify team. In fairness, it does offer an alternative view, and supplies some contradictory narrative from trade body, the Society of Motor Manufacturing and Traders (SMMT). But then it wheeled out Lord Deben, who “said going against CCC advice would “not be sensible” as it would “cost people money”. He said climate targets were “not random targets” and “if you don’t reach them then you put yourselves in really serious danger of having climate change, which we can’t handle”.” No attempt was made by the BBC to point out that the UK’s climate targets are in fact entirely random, having been decided on by politicians, who first arbitrarily opted for an 80% reduction in emissions by 2050, and then decided to go the whole hog and change the target to “net zero”. The CCC is legally obliged by the Climate Change Act (as thus amended) to set “carbon budgets” which in theory will enable the legally-binding (but nevertheless random) target to be achieved, but that fact doesn’t render the target any less random. The BBC also shied away from any challenge to the absurd claim that the UK’s failure to reach its targets puts the UK in really serious danger of having climate change, which we can’t handle, with the consequent inference that achieving the targets will either avoid climate change in the UK, or reduce it to a level which, presumably, we can “handle”.
The Guardian did slightly better. Its article was (almost identically) headed “UK will miss climate targets if it weakens EV sales rules, advisers warn”, but they added a sub-title: “Analysts say mooted move to let more petrol and diesel vehicles be sold would wreck plan to reach net zero by 2050”. You can always count on the Guardian – “would wreck” sounds so much more serious than, say, “might endanger” or “could risk”. Incidentally, the CCC letter nowhere uses the word “wreck”, which represents the Guardian’s own gloss on things – as the article acknowledges, “the CCC said the UK is “likely to miss” its climate targets if it confirms plans to allow more sales of petrol and diesel cars and vans in the next four years”.
In fairness, the Guardian did (in my opinion, at least) give more weight to the strong pushback from the SMMT:
The car industry criticised the CCC’s analysis. Mike Hawes, chief executive of the Society for Motor Manufacturers and Traders, said: “A successful EV transition needs a strong market and a competitive industry.
“The CCC, however, ignores the damaging cost of the targets it defends: billions in unsustainable discounts and millions more in government incentives.
“Contrary to the CCC’s claims, the mandate is deterring local investment, as however much manufacturers export, without a strong local market there is no business case to build here.”
When it comes to understanding the industry, I think it’s reasonable to assume that the CCC knows less about the effect of its targets on the car industry than does the SMMT. This, of course, is a problem with the CCC and its remit. Carbon budgets intrude into pretty much every aspect of life, and consequently the CCC has an opinion on every aspect of life. But while its members might (or might not) be “independent”, and while they might (or might not) be experts in the field of climate change and carbon budgets, they almost certainly know less about everything they seek to interfere with than do the people directly affected by their interference.
However, I digress. It’s worth analysing the CCC’s letter. It runs to 17 pages, including an “evidence annex” and numerous footnotes, but the meat of it comprises only two pages, with six main paragraphs, each with their own sub-headings. Let’s take a look.
It commences assertively and controversially, by insisting “that the mandate is working effectively”. Working for whom? Clearly the CCC discounts the informed views of the SMMT. Then it claims that “Weakening it would…miss an opportunity to reduce costs for a typical household by around £800 a year….”. The choice of words strikes me as careful and deliberate – an opportunity for a typical household, rather than a certaintly or even a likelihood. What is a typical household, I wonder? More on this below under the second headlined paragraph. Turning to those paragraphs:
Market growth for electric cars is ahead of the level required to meet the mandate’s current level of ambition out to 2030
This is a piece of legerdemain, claimed by reference to footnotes, including the SMMT’s own data. This shows new EVs (as opposed to hybrids) with a market share in the year to October of 26.6%. But as the Guardian article acknowledges:
Electric cars were 26.6% of UK new car sales during the first 10 months of 2026, well below the 33% headline target.
How, then, can the CCC make the claim that it does? Instead of acknowledging that there’s a problem, it waves a magic wand:
Flexibilities, which were expanded less than a year ago, have worked as intended, providing a significant buffer for manufacturers to comply without facing fines. The headline target for the ZEV mandate this year is 33% but once CO2 flexibilities are accounted for, manufacturers need to achieve around 25% to meet their obligations.
What it doesn’t explain is what happens next year and the year after that, if the increasingly strict targets aren’t relaxed. In that scenario it becomes increasingly difficult to roll over the numbers into the following year, and it starts to look increasingly like a Ponzi Scheme. It will, in my opinion, inevitably come crashing down.
It’s already putting the industry under great pressure. People still want ICE vehicles, but they are bing given less and less choice in that regard, not necessarily because the manufacturers and retailers want to deny their customers that choice, but because the ZEV mandate is forcing them down that route. Profits are being reduced as discounting of EVs takes place to try to persuade customers to buy expensive cars they can’t really afford. As the Evidence Annex to the letter states:
The increased supply of cheaper new models has helped reduce the average price premium on new electric cars from 37% at the end of 2023, to 16% at the end of 2025….BloombergNEF assess the manufacturing cost premium on EVs made in Europe to be 10% in 2025, while Renault claim they are profitable on several compact EV models…
Taken at face value, that is direct evidence that EVs cost more to make and cost more to buy than their ICE equivalents. The claim that Renault is profitable on several compact EV models carries with it the inevitable inference that Renault (and presumably other manufacturers) are unprofitable on other EV lines.
Weakening the mandate will miss an opportunity to lower the costs of driving. A typical household can save around £800 a year by switching to an electric car
There are no footnotes to justify this claim, which is based on the idea that “cutting the headline ZEV targets would increase fuel consumption in the UK by an equivalent of up to 15 million barrels of oil per year by 2030. At current prices, this would cost the UK more than £1 billion.” It relies, of course, on oil prices not falling from their current high prices, and I assume that is why it is only described as an “opportunity” to save money. The Guardian’s article very properly mirrors the language of the CCC letter, referring to the “opportunity”. Disgracefully, the BBC is much less circumspect and much less accurate:
The CCC says that switching to an electric vehicle can save a typical household around £800 a year, with fewer people benefiting if the targets were watered down.
My guess is that the CCC hoped that somebody would pick up the £800 claim and run with it. Even if that isn’t the case, there was always a chance it would happen, and the CCC was clearly happy to take that chance. But where exactly does the £800 figure come from, and what is a typical household? For this we need to turn to paragraph 2 of the Evidence Annex at page 7 of the CCC’s letter. Here we discover that the claim is based on “assuming mostly at-home charging”. Of course, this is unlikely to apply to a low-income family (are they not typical? Are they not the people who a Labour government should think about? Whatever happened to a “just transition”?). Even with that assumption rather dubiously in place, we then find that the £800 drops to “ around £400 a year” for low income families (“They save less than a typical household because we assume they drive less (and so generate lower fuel cost savings”).). There is also an additional assumption – that the savings are achieved by leasing, or buying second hand EVs, not by buying new ones. The EV mandate must be maintained, it is claimed, because “Weakening the mandate would reduce supply of affordable electric models which feed through to the used market.” Fair enough so far as it goes, but it seems to me to undermine the dramatic headline claim of possible £800 savings per annum. And of course, unspoken is the question of tax. If and when more people are driving EVs, and fewer are driving ICEs, the government’s tax take will fall. The current receipts from VAT and fuel duty on petrol and diesel are around £24-£25 billion per annum. Shift that to tax on EVs instead, and the putative £800 per annum saving per household disappears in a puff of smoke.
Rather sneakily, indeed, tucked away in the Evidence Annex, is this statement:
We have not included the cost of eVED in either the ‘before’ or ‘after’ Iran war estimates (unlike our 2026 Progress Report estimates) because this analysis is intended to show the current costs of EV ownership. However, households will still save on running costs even once eVED comes into effect.
The mandate helps ensure UK manufacturing keeps pace with the global shift to EVs and their value chains
This is presented by the CCC as an argument in favour of retaining the mandate, but I think it actually undermines it. If there is a vibrant export market for EVs, manufacturers will seek to take advantage of it without the need for a domestic ZEV mandate. If most cars manufactured in the UK are exported, are we not then importing the EVs that retailers are being forced by the mandate to sell? The CCC letter actually says:
Most British-made vehicles are made for export. The mandate, which applies only to domestic sales, does not apply to 77% of the cars made here.
Surely this renders the mandate marginal at best, otiose at worst, in terms of hitting carbon budgets. Indeed, the vast majority of EVs sold in the UK are imported, many from China.
Government benefits for plug-in hybrids (PHEVs) are distorting the market. Correcting this would support domestic manufacturers more than weakening the mandate.
In some ways, this reinforces my point above and weakens the CCC’s case:
The mandate also provides an artificially high baseline for new entrants based on 2021 averages, effectively subsidising Chinese PHEVs. New competitors are taking an increasing share of UK car sales across all fuel types.
Slowing the shift to electric vehicles also leaves van drivers and businesses exposed to the high cost of diesel.
Arguably the CCC undermines its opening argument (that the mandate is on track) in this paragraph:
The van transition has been challenging to date, primarily due to a lack of access to affordable public charging and the limited capability of early models….Government should re-commit to the transition to electric vans and focus on tackling barriers, while allowing manufactures enough breathing room in the meantime.
That doesn’t sound to me as though things are going well.
We welcome the Government’s support for climate targets, but targets are not enough – they must be matched with action.
Indeed, and that’s precisely the problem. The absurdly unrealistic (and, I repeat, entirely random) targets are now butting up against cold, hard reality. The low-hanging fruit has long been picked. It gets a lot harder from here on in.
Your department’s impact assessment implies that cutting headline targets in the mandate would materially reduce these emissions savings, which in turn would mean that the legal Sixth Carbon Budget target would not be met without alternative action at the same scale. The additional emissions from Option 3 in 2030 are equivalent to the emissions savings of approximately 2.8 million residential heat pump retrofits, and more than the total emissions from the paper and glass manufacturing sectors in 2025.
The CCC’s demand?
1. Maintain current headline targets for cars through to 2030. 2. Update the Utility Factor for PHEVs so the mandate credits real-world emissions reduction. 3. Level the playing field by tightening the CO2 baseline used to credit new market entrants. 4. Set post-2030 phase-out requirements which maximise electric-only driving capability. 5. Address barriers to accelerate electric van adoption. 6. Building on the Budget, bring forward further policies to reduce the cost of public charging and ensure future regulatory and fiscal decisions are coherent with delivering the mandate.
Conclusion
Barriers, costs, mandates, subsidies. It’s not straightforward, and it’s not cheap. I suspect the CCC is starting to become quite concerned. One thing leads to another. If the ZEV mandate is weakened, the Sixth Carbon Budget might not be achieved. If the Sixth Carbon Budget isn’t achieved, it casts doubts on the viability of Net Zero by 2050. If Net Zero by 2050 isn’t a realistic prospect, where does that leave the Climate Change Act, which mandates a target that can’t be achieved? If the Act is repealed, where does that leave the CCC? Facing abolition? One can live in hope.