This morning I thought I had better do my duty and have a look at the Government’s ZEV Mandate Review.
Upon opening it, I couldn’t stop a crushing weight from falling upon me. [It wasn’t a piano. It was helplessness.] The consultation PDF is 90 pages. Clicking through to the “Questions” section, I found that there are 45 questions. Of course, they do not want plebs responding, and they will do their utmost to build a citadel around the review to prevent them from so doing.
These two factoids made me question even the point of reading on. Read it, or just click on that little X in the top right hand corner? [All right, it’s not in the top right corner as I type this. It’s kind of in the middle, amongst a morass of tabs.]
I propose to begin at the beginning, and see how far I get. I do not see myself answering the questions. It would take far too long to formulate intelligent responses. The option to reply by saying “scrap the mandate” is unlikely to exist.
The beginning is the Ministerial Foreword.
OK, paragraph 1 opens with what is almost a logical fallacy, which is not very promising:
The UK’s transition to zero emission vehicles is vital not only for the environment, but for consumers and industry. For individual drivers, electric vehicles provide running cost savings of up to £1,400 per year, as well as insulation from fuel price shocks.
A transition that benefitted consumers would happen organically, without intervention, and would obviate the need for a Mandate or a Review of a Mandate. The saving in running costs are the result of political decisions to place a huge burden of duty and tax on petrol and diesel cars. Since the savings are phantoms, and the penalties of owning an ICE car are passed directly to the Treasury, it is sure that they will evaporate like Scarbo.
But soon his body developed a bluish tint, translucent like the wax of a candle, his face blanched like melting wax – and suddenly his light went out.
The next paragraph is also misleading. We in the UK are ahead of the game, it says. Yes: because of your carrot and stick policies. In fact, horse apples land on horse apples as we go down.
The UK government is investing record sums to make the most of these benefits, with £7.5 billion to grow the market, boost electric vehicle manufacturing, increase sales and build up the UK charging network.
The gov’t is wasting money on things that would develop on their own, if people wanted or needed them. As an obvious example, the government did not invest billions in rolling out petrol stations. Why does it need to do so for a charging network? There is an obvious risk of money being destroyed here. Next it says 160,000 have benefitted from the Electric Car Grant. Great. But this is a complete waste of cash. The people who need help are the ones dropping £1500 on credit on a 20-year-old car (and who then have a shock when they see the tax they have to pay to own it, at up to 50% of its value per year JUST FOR A LICENCE TO USE THE ROAD). No-one needs a grant off a new car retailing at £40K+. The grants, says the Foreword, have moved the cost of an EV “closer than ever” to that of an ICE. Irrelevant again, if the £1,400 per year saving actually mattered. Blah blah blah… 120,000 chargers already installed and 100,000 more in the pipeline. This circles back to the mythological line that people won’t go electric because “there is a lack of charging infrastructure.” As I said in Charging Towards the Future, EVs make up (or did then) 5.5% of the fleet, and we were already 40% (120K / 300K) of the way towards the targeted number of chargers. In other words, there are far more chargers per car now than there will be at the end of this “transition.”
To support this pace of change, this government has always been clear and consistent about our zero emission transition milestones – we are committed to phasing out new cars relying solely on internal combustion engines by 2030 and to 100% of new car and van sales being zero emission by 2035.
“…this government…” Yes. But now the united façade across politics has a big crack lacing it. I’d vote for a party who promises to end this mad scheme. I have a better approach. No mandates, no favouritism of one platform over another, fair taxation, support to keep older vehicles running rather than punitive road tax. That is surely greener than the make-believe idea that manufacturing emissions can be easily made good. The old cars have been built. They can run for many thousands of miles more, for the same emissions of manufacturing a new car. That is “obvious” even if in some quarters it is unpalatable.
Next, the Minister notes that there are a few headwinds. These are energy price increases, growing international competition and uncertainty re: how UK vehicles will be able to access export markets.
The pachyderm in the parlour is that people prefer the kind of car that is being banned. Not all of them. But a large enough proportion exists that no government committed to representing all its people would proceed with the ban.
These views [the responses to the review, i.e.] will inform our approach as the UK continues to transition to zero emission vehicles and as we continue to work together with industry to make Britain cleaner, more secure, and more prosperous.
“…make Britain cleaner” by doing mining, refining and manufacturing somewhere else, while taxing perfectly useable old cars off the road. [And, as noted, the beady eye of Sauron must then turn on the vehicles that are presently being promoted with tax breaks, so that money can be shovelled into the black hole at the Treasury.] Make Britain more secure, by importing vehicles with a permanent data connection to the parent company, which just happens to reside in the territory of a geopolitical rival (don’t laugh; a mouse and a combine both have their eyes on the same ear of wheat). Make Britain more prosperous? There seems to be a lot of hopium there. There is a free market case to allow cheap imports (as, for example, the now-ubiquitous “Temu Range Rover,” the Jaecoo 7). I don’t think this should apply here, for the simple reason that the bar to entry is such that once lost, complex manufacturing is very hard to regrow. Maybe, if push came to shove, we could start making our own grommets again. But security must imply at least some home-grown capability for every essential, and without that, prosperity is a hostage to fortune.
Well, that’s about the end of the Foreword, and I’ve already pegged my cynicism meter. I’ll read the rest of the consultation, when I’ve recovered. That may take some time. Whatever I find out, I’ll post in comments below, unless anyone else feels a burst of enthusiasm and beats me to it.
Political sideswipe
Meanwhile, the Burnt Ham has announced that one sort of scallywag or the other is not going to be let out of jail early, but several other kinds are. [When they were wheeling out Minister after Minister to say “We’ve looked at this, turned over every rock, et cetera, and there’s literally nothing we can do,” it was perfectly obvious that a shrieking 180 was inevitable.] He does not seem to have got the hang of running the country. Did he wake up one day and find himself PM, with no memory of how he came to take up the highest office in the land? [“Wow. I’m the PM? How did that happen?] A couple of weeks ago, I heard him say, and I paraphrase lightly, [and put on Burnham’s accent when you read this] “Ever since I came into office, weeks ago, I’ve been pushing on this topic every day. Now I think we have managed to find a solution.”
Dude, you’re the PM, not the teaboy. [Put Churchill’s voice on, and repeat my misquote of Burnham.]
As to the miscreants themselves, they supposedly have to be let out because they are too crowded inside, and therefore the rest of us have to be put into a larger jail (the country, i.e.). I have no problem with multiples in cells. I do have a problem with anything more technologically advanced than a book in a cell. The problem with sharing cells is that the poor sods have got to share the same space with someone who is probably not the nicest guy you ever met, for almost the entire day. Out of the cells early, and back in late, I would say, and make sharing work because for most of the time the occupants are asleep. Naturally, that leaves the problem of what to do with prisoners between 8am and 10pm. Work, education or training might be an idea, especially if you are planning on releasing them to mingle with the law-abiding masses. Maybe start off with some hard exercise before breakfast and move on from there. We can’t afford that? Well, it’s all a matter of priorities. We spend more on debt interest than education.
/message ends
==
PS. If, like me, you were prepared to give the government one chance to prove it would not abuse the emergency alert siren, the advice to avoid juggling with lit sticks of dynamite because A&E was busy probably came as a disappointment. The good news is that there is an easy way to turn it off. Of course, there is always the possibility that the government will override my overriding of their control over my device. We’ll see.
There aren’t many days when I don’t feel a crushing weight of helplessness and despair, and like you it’s not the piano what’s doing it 🙄
But you made me smile this morning, so thank you, I do like a dollop of cynicism laced with a dollop of humour.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hmm … ‘Scarbo’? I don’t think you meant THIS – no sign of that disappearing. On the contrary. No, it must have been the Ravel.
As always, well done Jit. Thanks.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Cure for the nanny state emergency alert … stop using a mobile phone.
Radical, yes but it would stop the surveillance state in its tracks. Merely reverting to a ‘dumbphone’ would help.
I had one and it worked fine 1997-2014. Then it failed. I stopped using a mobile in late 2018 because the build quality of the two I tried could be termed plastic s**t.
After all, I’ve had a large screen on my desk since the early 1980s. I’ve generally been satisfied with that.
LikeLike
“Sunderland gets its Kicks: Nissan to invest £170m to build new hybrid SUV
Latest attempt to secure future of Britain’s biggest car factory may be subject to UK weakening EV sales mandate”
https://www.theguardian.com/business/2026/sep/16/sunderland-nissan-kicks-170m
LikeLiked by 1 person
“Scrap ‘delusional’ electric car sales targets, Renault boss says
Auto company’s UK chief warns EV demand has ‘not kept pace’ with Government’s mandate”
https://archive.ph/YQZrc#selection-2615.4-2619.89
LikeLiked by 2 people
From that Telegraph link –
“The chief executive of one of Britain’s biggest car dealerships has said “delusional” electric vehicle (EV) targets are damaging the economy. Robert Forrester, boss of Vertu Motors, said a desperate scramble to hit the targets was diverting money from investment and jobs towards discounts meant to entice drivers to buy EVs. “You get into a nasty vicious circle of discounting, then discounting, then discounting, to try and keep pace with a target that has no relation in free market capitalism,” he said.
The policy risked damage not only to the car industry but also to the wider economy, Mr Forrester added.”
Seems this has been stated before, many times, and nothing changes.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Autocar reports more special pleading from the leasing companies for extra support in the imminent budget:
https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-news/company-cars/leasing-firms-%E2%80%9Cbloodbath%E2%80%9D-electric-car-market-needs-budget-support
LikeLike
“Policy U-turn could stall Britain’s take-up of electric vehicles
The 2030 target for 80% of new cars to have zero emissions could be cut to as low as half”
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2026/oct/25/policy-u-turn-uk-electric-vehicles
Looks like a shameless bit of lobbying by the ECIU, aided and abetted by the Guardian, so far as I can see,
LikeLike
Mark; I read that, last month, Chinese-made cars took nearly a quarter of the UK market. I sus pect it’s squeaky-bum time inside govt.
LikeLike
“Labour expected to cut EV targets for UK’s car industry despite MPs’ protests
Exclusive: Louise Haigh likely to weaken mandate for sales that forms key part of emission reduction plan”
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2026/nov/08/labour-cut-ev-target-car-industry-despite-climate-concerns
LikeLike
George Monbiot is at it again at the Guardian:
“Why are Britain’s streets still so polluted? Because the car industry dinosaurs do what they like, and politicians let them
The transition to electric vehicles should be moving apace, but it is not. And why? Incompetence, expedience and cowardice”
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/nov/11/britain-streets-polluted-car-industry-electric-vehicles-transition
I particularly liked this bit:
If you can charge them at home…But George, unlike your average Guardian reader, most people can’t charge them at home, so they’re not cheap to run. Equally to the point, if we ever do reach an EV tipping point, the government will stop treating EV owners with kid gloves and will hit them with the same taxes that make ICE vehicles expensive to run. They’re going to have to fill the £30 billion black hole it will leave somehow.
The key point is that Mr Monbiot can rage against big business all he likes. He misses the key point – people don’t want EVs. But apparently we have to be made to want them, whether we like it or not.
LikeLike
“Weakening UK electric vehicle targets would hurt car industry, ministers told
Exclusive: Experts say watering down ZEV mandate would slow market and hamper efforts to reduce cost of living”
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2026/nov/16/weakening-uk-electric-vehicle-targets-would-hurt-car-industry-ministers-told
Who are these “experts”? The Climate Change Committee and Net Zero campaigners, it seems. How many of them have run a car manufacturer or car sales business? In what sense, in this context, are they experts? What do the real experts have to say?
LikeLiked by 1 person
“Not banning newspapers would harm newsagents, experts say.”
LikeLiked by 1 person
If anything suggests it’s time to abolish the Climate Change Committee (and goodness knows, plenty does) this article from the BBC today is it:
“Government risks missing climate targets if EV rules weakened, adviser warns”
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c63rgqg5l9l2o
“Can” rather than “will”. And what’s a “typical” household? I don’t see those savings being achieved by the majority of households, which don’t have their own home charging arrangements, and which have to rely on public charging points, often some distance from where they live. We don’t all live in London, after all. And by the time you factor in costs of purchase and depreciation costs, it’s difficult to see any savings at all, even while petrol and diesel costs are (perhaps temporarily) high. Then what happens when the government starts taxing EVs in the way that ICE cars are taxed? After all, they’ll have to fill an almost £30 billion tax shortfall somehow. Once it’s a level playing field, any putative cost savings disappear (and worse).
Quite. Meanwhile Deben has re-emerged to spout nonsense:
Wrong on all counts. Abandoning the targets will save people money, not least the taxpayer, which is still subsidising EVs. And the targets are utterly random. How meeting the targets avoids climate change while missing them brings it on is anyone’s guess. With UK emissions around 0.7% of global emissions, and any shift from ICE vehicles to EVs in new car sales being an infinitesimally small proportion of that, Lord Deben’s comment is nonsense on stilts.
LikeLiked by 2 people
All quite mad.
LikeLike
There are times when disagreements are primarily political (“we’d be better off in the EU,” vs “we are better off out of the EU.”) But here Deben has strayed into stating as fact something that is demonstrably, and obviously, false. It is disappointing that the BBC is willing to report such disinformation. (Their get-out clause is that Deben is a senior figure whose opinion should be reported. This is how they defended their stance on the Pakistan floods, which as Mark noted, has been recycled recently.)
Unfortunately, BBC Verify only come out to bat against things they disapprove of, so there will be no hope of correct information for any BBC readers with only a superficial knowledge of these things.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Fair play to the Guardian, for this quote in an article which otherwise is very similar to the article in the BBC website:
LikeLiked by 1 person
House of Lords – The conduct of Lord Deben – Committee for Privileges and Conduct
“ANNEX 1: REPORT FROM THE SUB-COMMITTEE ON LORDS’ CONDUCT
1. The Commissioner for Standards has submitted the attached report dismissing a complaint made against Lord Deben.
2. The complainant alleged that Lord Deben failed to register his position as a “Council Member” of the World Future Council. The World Future Council is a global organisation which seeks to inform policy makers about future ethical decision-making.
3. The Commissioner found Lord Deben not to have breached the Code of Conduct as the position he held was more akin to ordinary membership of a not-for-profit organisation (which need not be registered) than being an office holder (which must be registered).
4. We recommend that the Committee for Privileges and Conduct should make a report to the House on this case.”
Parliamentary copyright 2013“
LikeLiked by 1 person
Had a quick “World Future Council” search – World Future Council
The site is a mess, maybe my browser. Is it active now ?
Anyway, noticed the contact at the bottom – “WFC HEADQUARTERS World Future Council
c/o Club of Rome Deutschland Rosenstr. 220095 Hamburg”. bold mine.
LikeLike