The news that 50,000 people are working in the Scottish renewables sector should be taken with a very large pinch of salt. Even as reported we learn that it is based on Office for National Statistics survey data with a model of the Scottish economy, because renewable energy is not separately identified in the National Accounts. We are also told that survey uncertainty, revisions to official data and an updated economic model mean the results should not be compared directly with previous editions. These caveats, taken together, suggest either that previous reports, or this one, can not be regarded as truly accurate.

The Report is presented as independent, having been conducted by the Fraser of Allander Institute (FAI) at the University of Strathclyde. However, it was commissioned by Scottish Renewables, so the intent behind it was clearly to propagandise in favour of the Scottish renewable energy industry. One of the key words running through the Report is “estimate”. The 50,000 jobs turn out to be an estimate of around 49,200 full-time equivalent (FTE) jobs. The estimates, we are told, are also subject to revision as further survey responses are received and as methods are improved. How independent is the Report? Its authors appear to support the official narrative – the following is taken from the Report’s introduction:

In Scotland, technologies like offshore and onshore wind, solar panels, heat pumps, and marine energy are already playing a key role in cutting carbon emissions and supporting future energy security. Alongside these environmental benefits, the renewable energy sector also brings important economic advantages. It supports jobs, attracts investment, and creates positive effects across other parts of the economy. This report draws on an input-output model of the Scottish economy to estimate how much economic activity is currently supported by the renewable energy sector.

What is the renewable energy sector? Who knows? It is not currently defined by National Statistics. Instead, the Report has constructed a hypothetical renewable energy sector. It’s difficult to know what that means, but it’s easy to see that the most generous gloss has been put on this – for example, of the 49,200 FTE “supported by” Scotland’s renewable energy sector (Table 4), 825 are in arts, entertainment and recreation; 350 are in public admin and defence; 375 are in water supply, sewerage and waste; 1,135 are in finance and insurance ;200 are in mining and quarrying. And so it goes on, with jobs seemingly being re-labelled to suit the narrative. Almost incredibly, 5,050 are said to be in electricity and gas.

As well as repeated use of the word “estimate”, the Report also relies a great deal on modelling. Page 7 rightly contains the following caveat:

…it is important to interpret these figures with some caution. The estimates are based on statistics which involve relatively small sample sizes at this level of detail. As a result, there is a wider margin of uncertainty around the numbers.

The Report runs to no more than 12 pages. Its analysis is too short and too simple to allow detailed scrutiny. For instance, of the jobs said to be supported by the Scottish renewables sector, we are not told how many of the workers concerned are UK citizens and how many are foreign nationals. We know that many of the renewable energy companies working in Scotland and hoovering up taxpayer-funded subsidies are foreign-owned. We know that much of the money paid to them goes abroad. The Report fails to analyse such issues.

The front cover image for the report was provided by SSE. A cynic might ponder whether he who pays the piper calls the tune.

8 Comments

  1. Mark,

    I see a lot of numbers in the report. I also see the words ‘approximately’ and ‘margin of error’. However, none of the numbers provided seem to be used to quantify those words. As a result, I think it is safe to say that the whole report is valueless. And just to quantify that: it has absolutely zero value with no margin for error.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Reminds me of A Comparison of Electricity Transmission Technologies:
    Costs and Characteristics
    An Independent Report by Mott MacDonald in Conjunction with the IET

    It was also made out to be an independent study but was simply an example of designing the experiment to get the required results. It was commissioned by the three transmission operators and the head of the editorial board was Prof Keith Bell, who runs an academic dept at Strathclyde which is sponsored by Scottish Power. He literally owes them his academic status and title. The whole thing was rigged to show that undergrounding transmission cables was too expensive.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Mark – thanks for another find. Found this bit eyepopping –

    “The report highlighted several major developments during 2023-24, including the opening of South Kyle Wind Farm in 2023, which generated £44 million in local spending and is expected to deliver £38 million in lifetime community benefits.”

    Found this – South Kyle Wind Farm – Vattenfall – which quotes “Over its lifetime, South Kyle Wind Farm is expected to deliver an estimated £38 million in community benefit funding for Carsphairn, Dalmellington, New Cumnock and Patna through the South Kyle Community Benefit Fund.”

    So good for the community’s I suppose, but shows the profits must be vast. As for the £44 million bit, no idea, unless all the local pubs/hotels are cashing in, hope so.

    Like

  4. dfhunter,

    Did you spot the slight of hand? Vattenfall (the foreign owners of the wind farm, who will be taking money out of the UK economy) talks of “an estimated £38 million in community benefit funding“. By the time this information (presumably lifted from the wind farm website, and not independently checked) reaches the Report, it’s an expectation, no longer an estimate. Arguably there’s not much different, but arguably there is. The number will be a firm one in the Report’s tables. No doubt this is replicated many times.

    Like

  5. Perhaps the report was a prelude to this campaign:

    “SNP putting ‘thousands of jobs at risk’ with failure to triple Scotland’s onshore wind capacity”

    https://www.scotsman.com/news/politics/snp-scotland-onshore-wind-renewables-jobs-9327679

    SNP ministers have been urged to draw up plans to triple Scotland’s onshore wind capacity by 2040 – with the industry warning it would support thousands of jobs and add billions to the economy.

    The potentially controversial move could see more than 1,000 new wind farms built across Scotland’s countryside over the next 14 years….

    …The industry has warned that a risk of failing to set out a long-term strategy for onshore wind risks undermining investment, supply chain growth and future energy planning.

    Now, the Scottish Onshore Wind Developers Forum (SOWDF) is calling on the Scottish government to set out an intention to ramp up onshore wind capacity, which has the potential to receive a backlash from communities if benefits are not seen at a local level…..

    Like

  6. “1,000 new wind farms built across Scotland’s countryside over the next 14 years” – aaahhh

    Can the grid cope ? who cares.

    Like

Leave a Reply